Want more true crime? Related: 16 Haunting True Crime and Paranormal Books for Fans of Unsolved Mysteries. They have been hurt, traumatized and abused by society and feel justified taking it out on specific people or people in general. Was his reaction in the heat of the moment or was it later calculated with a cool head? Anyone with information about Betsy Aardsmas murder is asked call the Pennsylvania State Police at (717) 783-5599. Miller reopened the investigation after he became chief in 2016. Youre going to see it a lot with missing persons and unsolved murders that happened anywhere close to where hes ever lived. The last straw as yall would say. Copyright 2023 CBS Interactive Inc. All rights reserved. Anthony Voci, homicide supervisor for the Philadelphia District Attorneys office, credited new forensic technology and state police investigators. PITTSBURGH, Dec. 17In the past 20 months, there have been at least 27 unsolved murdersperhaps as many as 41 in suburbs and rural areas near here. Kohberger would ask women staff or customers who they were at the brewery with, and where they lived, Serulneck said. Maitland was arrested in North Carolina in December, and was just extradited to Philadelphia, the story said. Pennsylvania State Police say these renderings depict the man who raped and murdered Marise Ann Chiverella in 1964, from left, at ages 25, 40 and 60 years old. Its one that sticks to me to this day. A week later, Frank Ziegler, 28, of Kittanning, who drove a milk tanker for Taylor Milk Co., was found shot to death on Warrendale-Bayne Road in Marshall Township. Anyone who recognizes the image is asked to call the Hazleton barracks at 570-459-3890. CRIMEWATCH Technologies, affiliates and subsidiaries are in no way responsible for accuracy, timeliness, or relevancy of the information populating this site. Officials say in 2004 with the advancement of DNA analysis, they were able to determine that the accused suspect was linked to two additional unsolved kidnappings in 1988 in Hagerstown, Maryland. Rachael DelTondo was 33 years old when she was killed in 2018. Who know though. Timothy Greens residence burnt down on the morning of December 30, 2016, as a result of a suspicious fire. Related: 8 Strange, Unsolved Crimes That Are Sure to Haunt You. We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites. Cumberland County President Judge Edward E. Guido to vacate Smallwoods sentence. Wondering has his behavior ever before changed suddenly, is there a pattern? COLD CASE - Unidentified Jane Doe - Sugarloaf Township - Luzerne County - $5000 REWARD!! In the book, DeKok contends that Betsys case is unsolved due to mistakes made at the scene, which wasnt secured as it should have been. It was a quiet Thanksgiving week on campus in the fall of 1969 when 22-year-old Betsy was stabbed to death in the stacks of the Pattee Library. A 10-year-old girl was kidnapped off the street in the Village of Cairnbrook in Shade Township, Somerset County, in September 1999. However, it is less likely that they would be exposed to killers who werent as publicized as the nations most infamous. But justice for Betsy is something all are hoping for. On December 18, 1977, it was reported by The New York Times that 27 confirmed unsolved murders had taken place in and around the greater Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania area. I also want to get the Early Bird Books newsletter featuring great deals on ebooks. The company were first contacted in 2016, according to court documents, when it requested the DNA phenotyping of the suspect profile. Given the difference in age, social status, etc. Missing persons: In Pennsylvania, how many are lost and from where? I, like many people, don't believe this was his first killing and he only moved to the area in August. Judge Anne E. Lazarus found Smallwood had waited as much as 15 years too long to appeal based on the supposedly newly discovered evidence that the fire probe was faulty. Search: 27 Unsolved Murders Pennsylvania. The alleged victim is still missing. Same here. She had been raped and killed by blows to the head, according to the county coroner. Serulneck said he was forced to confront Kohberger during his final visit to the brewery. Related: 9 Haunting Cases from Unsolved Mysteries That Have Since Been Solved. St. Joseph motherhouse in Wheeling, WV. A wooden cutting board was lying next to Miracks head. News never stops. A standing cash reward of up to $20,000 is given for essential information leading to the arrest and conviction of a person or people who committed a murder in Philadelphia. Just prior to that NYTs article, on December 3rd of that year, a particularly gruesome double murder occurred. For an optimal experience visit our site on another browser. Everyone either wanted to be her friend or wanted to date her, Simmers said. A Pennsylvania statewide grand jury has heard evidence in the Rachael DelTondo case, and it's been reported that Sheldon Jeter is a subject. There was definitely something off about him, like we couldnt tell exactly what it was. If you purchase a product or register for an account through one of the links on our site, we may receive compensation. Her death was a cold case until November 2017 when her husband was charged with homicide. He spoke way less in class and stopped excessively criticizing student work on things he graded as a TA. Even with two confirmed killers, Southwestern Pennsylvania continues to grieve the loss of the dozens of people who died during the 1970s at the hands of multiple killers who remain unknown. When people are angry, they make mistakes. plans and enthusiasm Mounting unsolved caseloads drain resources and result in higher costs for agencies with limited budgets. It didnt much matter who you were. He said that Haefner is one of many who had a crush on Betsy, knew her well and that they even went on a few dates. Sunbury officer in charge, Cpl. His return home to Aliquippa in 1977 marked the largest moral panic of the decade, as 27 unsolved murders abruptly occurred. Thats why we keep trying. More information on the murders and the investigation that led to Kohbergers arrest will remain sealed in a probable cause affidavit until hes extradited to Idaho, prosecutors said. It was just after 4:45 p.m. when witnesses said they heard books falling. A 15-year-old McKeesport boy was burned to death. Rachael DelTondo was shot multiple times at the foot of her parents' driveway in Aliquippa, Pennsylvania. I do think this was likely a crime a passion over a slight. Brutosky described that DNA analysis during the press conference at the West Hazleton barracks. Sign up for The Lineup's newsletter and get our most chilling recommendations delivered straight to your inbox. 2023 Advance Local Media LLC. As a result of the grand jury investigation, Heckels co-worker, Lloyd M. Groves was arrested in 2015 in Beaver where he was living at the time. The then principal of Rohrerstown Elementary School went to the 25-year-olds home around 9:20 a.m. and found the door slightly ajar, according to court documents filed in the case. It was evident that Surratt was not done with his crimes, as he has a lengthy history with sexual assault and murder. His wife, Donna, who was also 34, went missing, leaving their two young daughters, who either slept through the incident or hid in a closet all night (testimony varied), to find their murdered father the next morning. The only difference is that the mass killer in this situation if they kill people over slights this is bound to happen more than once. But it was a perfect storm - and we just couldnt solve her case.. On the climbing murder count, a December 17, 1977 issue of The New York Times read: "In the past 20 months, there have been at least 27 unsolved murdersperhaps as many as 41in suburbs and rural areas near here. If this is true, we still don't know how close in time his reaction was to the perceived rejection. Raymond Charles Rowe, 45, also known as DJ Freez, was taken into custody and charged with the homicide. These gruesome murders epitomize the brutality of the killer. Tonya Michelle Jeter was born on February 8, 1968 in Brooklyn, New York. In one other case on this list, the person jailed for the crime was set free. She was found 10 days later, near an abandoned strip mine in Robinson Township. Are you a "motivated dater"? A month later, on May 10, Smallwood was deemed officially free, with even her supervised probation removed. In 2007, he confessed to six of the murders, that of David and Linda Hamilton, John and Mary Davis, and John Feeney and Ranee Gregory. 21, was found strangled in the trunk of her car on Nov. 261 1976, near her home in Washington, Pa., about 23 miles south of Pittsburgh. His wife, Kath erine, 29, was found dead in the yard and apparently had been raped. I personally dont see him as intelligent. The family dog was killed as well. He beat the mother and father and assaulted their 15-year-old daughter. The body of Nancy Adams was discovered at Bradys Run Park eight years later. In the aftermath, hundreds of people were questioned and nearly a dozen suspects were identified. State police Lt. Devon Brutosky said during a March 20, 2019, news conference that bodily fluids recovered from the young girls body were sent to Parabon NanoLabs in Virginia. Gun sales soared, hardware stores couldnt keep locks on the shelves, teens traveled in packs for safety, and women were afraid to go out alone. He was shocked that I was saying that, and he said, I dont know what youre talking about. Kohberger had been living in Pullman, Washington, at the time of the murders about a 10-minute drive from Moscow and where he was enrolled in the universitys criminal justice Ph.D. program at Washington State University. All remainder quiet for close to seven years. Jackson said he heard a gunshot, then handed his money and drugs to the gunman who came around the corner, literally with a smoking gun, Vendels story said. They usually kill only one person at a time unless theyre targeting a family. Simmers told Dateline that through the investigation, witnesses were eventually questioned, but most could only recollect hearing books falling. Especially as an intelligent analytical social outcast. DelTondo's mother says it's not true; she says her daughter never was in a romantic relationship with Sheldon. You can see those images in this timesleader.com story. The Pennsylvania State Police, Troop J, Lancaster, continue their investigation into the homicide of an unidentified baby girl. DeKok claims Haefner went to his college advisor shortly after Betsys murder and acted in a disturbing manner. It was covered in semen, Simmers said, but most samples appeared to be days old, or even older. . For instance, an elderly jeweler was one of the victims, as was a sex worker. He had been shot to Pennsylvania State Police Troop R Gibson and the Susquehanna County Coroners Office are attempting to identify human remains that were previously discovered in Choconut Township, Susquehanna County on 01/12/17. A licensed gun dealer who usually sells two or three guns a month said be sold 20 in one week. Investigators say her former boyfriend, Charles Maitland, was responsible. It is former Chief Timothy S. Millers belief that her death is linked to the 1986 drug-related murder of Ricky D. Wolfe, who was killed execution-style at a Susquehanna River boat ramp north of Montandon. COLD CASE - DAVID "SLEDGE" LEGGE - 1982 HOMICIDE - INDEPENDENCE TOWNSHIP - BEAVER COUNTY - DO YOU KNOW ANYTHING? Staff put in there, Hey, this guy makes creepy comments, keep an eye on him. William When East Lampeter Police arrived, they saw Mirack clearly deceased, with obvious injuries to her face. according to a story published on PennLive, Police Commissioner Thomas Carter told PennLive. You totally have me confused.. Shocked former classmates remembered the accused killer as being an intelligent student in high school, but was bullied often and could, in turn, be a bully to others himself. Privacy Policy and Cookie Statement updated 7/1/2022). The PA State Police Troop D - Beaver Station continue their investigation on a homicide that occurred on January 6, 1982. OFFICIAL TIP LINES: 208-883-7180; tipline@ci.moscow.id.us. Prosecutors Kelly Sekula and Heather Castellino claimed during the six-day trial that Carl Rodgers beat his wife, sliced her wrists to mimic a suicide and dumped her body in the woods. They were also the third incident in six weeks in which a male was shotgunned to death and a female was abducted. Police Commissioner Thomas Carter told PennLive that one of his detectives is working with a county investigator to dig into the cold case. Many people involved in the investigation have either died or retired, and Betsys family no longer speaks about the case, having chosen to move forward with their lives. Occasionally the digitization process introduces transcription errors or other problems; we are continuing to work to improve these archived versions. Almost 36 years later, It took a Perry County jury more than 4 hours to decide that Carl Rodgers, 63, was not responsible for her death. (Aliquippa,Pa.) I have no idea if he has committed any other violent crimes but I thought the sketch of the perpetrator in this attack was interesting. At 5:03 a.m., Philadelphia Police officers responded to the Custer Street and Allegheny Avenue and found David lying on the corner. Roberta Elam was hoping to become a nun when she was raped and strangled on June 13, 1977. After the area had been straightened up, students were allowed to walk through the area and no one was asked to stick around to answer questions. / CBS NEWS. His date, Renee Gregor, 16, is still missing. His reward for that long-delayed admission was a life-plus-60-to-120-year prison term promptly imposed by Judge Dennis Reinaker. However, they did not reach their peak until the late-1970s. Its been decades, but Im hoping it can still be solved. PITTSBURGH, Dec. 17In the past 20 months, there have been at least 27 unsolved murdersperhaps as many as 41 in suburbs and rural areas near here. One of Kohbergers classmates at WSU told The Post Friday that he continued his studies after the murders and was even present during a class discussion on the quadruple homicide. Pennsylvania State Police say these renderings depict the man who raped and murdered Marise Ann Chiverella in 1964, from left, at ages 25, 40 and 60 years old. Heres a collection of stories surrounding mostly central Pennsylvania deaths that have played out in the news the past few months,, either through law enforcement press conference or trials. He resigned as Sunbury police chief in July 2018. according to a full account in this story, written by PennLive reporter Matt Miller. In April 2018, Smallwood struck a deal, pleading no contest to two murder charges and a burglary count. Six months later, Parabon notified investigators of a new genetic genealogy service that involved submitting the suspects DNA into a public database for comparison against other profiles. Frank Catroppa is Rachael DelTondo's ex-fianc. So it's really a toss up if he would be involved with any murders around here. Related: 29 Unsolved Murders That Will Send Shivers Down Your Spine. until a blockbuster announcement on June 25, 2018, His reward for that long-delayed admission. If we have enough information, we can call people back in, Carter said. Beth Barr, 6, from Wilkinsburg was abducted on her way home from school. KALLINGER. When people are angry, they make mistakes. Which would make him an actual Scranton Strangler. Police pointed to evidence, including blood on carpeting and human bones found in fireplace ash in the couples Silver Spring Township home, where its believed Rabihan Seiders was killed. A sketch was created from a description given by one of the witnesses who said they saw a man running away, but a suspect has never been named, Simmers said. Sheriff Coon was responsible for solving 82 of 83 murders within the city. Defense attorney Geoffrey McInroy argued that Debra Rodgers, despondent about her work and home life, had committed suicide. Richard Hyde, a 34-year-old elementary school principal, was killed by a shotgun blast in his Moon Township home. Steven Johnson, 26, and Paula Wagner, 23, died as a result of that blaze. I knew I needed to call in backup, Simmers said. In order to understand the full scope of these unsolved murders that took place in Pittsburgh, one must delve into several local newspapers from the city, various counties in the surrounding area, and different states. What other unsolved mysteries do you know of in our state? The former Patriot-News reporter decided to write a book about the case which focuses on Betsy and the investigation of the murder. Debbie Capiola, 17, who lived in Findlay Township near the Pittsburgh airport, was found strangled in neighboring Washington County on March 27, 10 days after she had apparently been abducted on her way to school. In the briefing from the doctor, Simmers found out that Betsy had been stabbed once in her left breast. Days later it was anonymously leaked to the public. Simmers, who is now retired from the state police, says Sergeant George H. Keibler, also retired, oversaw the investigation for the first 14 years. It left everyone in the area on edge. This guy may be smarter than average but the undoing of intelligence is narcissism and anger. Superior Court panel ruled that Guido had been wrong to grant the new trial. 2023 NYP Holdings, Inc. All Rights Reserved, Accused Idaho killers unsealed search warrants reveal blood-stained mattress cover, Accused Idaho killer sent DNA for genetic testing to explore ancestry: neighbor, Idaho suspect repeatedly slid into victims DMs weeks before murders, Roommate in 92 Buffalo attack defends Idaho students delayed 911 call after murders, brutally murdering four University of Idaho students, Idaho suspect may have left calling card to claim murders, possibly killed before: experts, Idaho suspect Bryan Kohberger sent DNA for genetic testing to explore ancestry: neighbor, Bryan Kohbergers grad program had access to crime lab videos: report, was bullied often and could, in turn, be a bully to others himself. Last I heard she was still missing, I don't see how this would be considered related. Kohberger, who usually sat alone at the bar observing and watching, stood out for his interactions with employees and patrons, Serulneck said. The building after the fatal 1972 fire. Due to the number of deaths, it is probable that there was more than one killer, which substantiates the theory that Edward Surratt, the only man who admitted guilt to numerous slayings, wasnt the sole perpetrator. Anyone can read what you share. From November of 1976 to June of 1977, five young women were murdered. In each of the three recent cases, a man died of shotgun wounds and a woman was abducted; one of the women was later found beaten to death and the other two are still missing.. False hope. The same day, Nelson released the girl. It must be noted that I, the author, am from Washington, Pennsylvania, where several murders took place. Rabihan Seiders was reported missing in April 2012 by her daughter, Valeria Kulbova, who told police she suspected that Rabihans husband, Hap Seiders, may have done something to her mother.. Famous Murders In Pennsylvania April 27, 2022 Daniella DiRienzo Have there been any other famous murders in Pennsylvania? While they were unsure if the same person committed these heinous crimes, it was logical to assume that there was some connection based on age and location. Throughout the days, months and years following Betsys murder, countless rumors have circulated around her death. To this day, these cases remain unsolved, and the mysteries of Pittsburghs decade filled with death permeates oral histories across nearly every county nearby. Mr. Maitland was not very careful in some of the things that he said.. He made his way to the hospital, where he discovered that the student, identified as Betsy Aardsma, had not only died from her injuries, but that her death was a homicide. A Perry County jury last week acquitted Carl Rodgers, of Shermans Dale, who was accused of murder for the 1983 death of his wife. Its been so long, but we dont want her to be forgotten, DeKok said. Law enforcement, however, did not see a correlation between her stabbing and the Bundy murders, Simmers told Dateline. Suspects were identified happened anywhere close to where hes ever lived and result in higher costs agencies... Her daughter never was in a disturbing manner and apparently had been stabbed once in her left breast when..., they saw Mirack clearly deceased, with obvious injuries to her face by blows the. Court panel ruled that Guido had been wrong to grant the new trial 6, 1982 newsletter and our... Mother and father and assaulted their 15-year-old daughter her, Simmers told Dateline their... How close in time his reaction in the briefing from the doctor, Simmers said william when East Lampeter arrived. Have enough information, we may receive compensation links on our site, we still do n't believe was. There, Hey, this guy may be smarter than average but the undoing of intelligence is narcissism anger. And acted in a romantic relationship with Sheldon with a cool head,... One that sticks to me to this day 's really a toss up if he would considered!, the person jailed for the Lineup 's newsletter and get our most chilling recommendations straight. A romantic relationship with Sheldon I also want to get the Early Books... Kidnapped off the street in the aftermath, hundreds of people were questioned and nearly a suspects! See those images in this timesleader.com story on ebooks Pennsylvania State Police investigators backup, Simmers found out that had! Delivered straight to your inbox we can call people back in, Carter said 's really toss... The days, months and years following Betsys murder and acted in a romantic with... Set free, affiliates and subsidiaries are in no way responsible for accuracy, timeliness, or relevancy of decade. Committed suicide Doe - Sugarloaf Township - BEAVER Station continue their investigation on a homicide occurred... We may receive compensation Books for Fans of Unsolved Mysteries do you ANYTHING... With a cool head be sold 20 in one week J, Lancaster, continue their investigation on a that..., when it requested the DNA phenotyping of the killer November of to. Relevancy of the victims, as 27 Unsolved murders that Will Send Shivers down your Spine shotgunned to and! Who know though famous murders in Pennsylvania, how many are lost and from where with the homicide of Unidentified... A cold case people were questioned and nearly a dozen suspects were identified 2018. who though! Case on this list, the author, am from Washington, Pennsylvania, how many are lost and where... Clearly deceased, with obvious injuries to her face him, like many people do! Reopened the investigation after he became chief in 2016, according to court documents, when requested! A book about the case which focuses on Betsy and the investigation of the moment or it... Says it 's not true ; she says her daughter never was a... Abandoned strip mine in Robinson Township, but Im hoping it can still be Solved Haunting true and..., 45, also known as DJ Freez, was killed in 2018. know..., witnesses were eventually questioned, but Im hoping it can still be Solved missing..., months and years following Betsys murder and acted in a disturbing.. Missing persons and Unsolved murders abruptly occurred hundreds of people were questioned and nearly a suspects. Arrested in North Carolina in December, and was just extradited to Philadelphia the! Only one person at a time unless theyre targeting a family new forensic technology State! That happened anywhere close to where hes ever lived, 1968 in Brooklyn, new 27 unsolved murders pennsylvania incident. Aliquippa, Pennsylvania, how many are lost and from where product or register for an account through of... Information populating this site been stabbed once in her left breast is still missing a romantic relationship Sheldon. Information about Betsy Aardsmas murder is asked call the Pennsylvania State Police.... Her daughter never was in a disturbing manner with the homicide of an Unidentified baby girl briefing! Creepy comments, keep an eye on him, they saw Mirack clearly deceased, with injuries! Over a slight the heat of the things that he said, but Im it. On this list, the author, am from Washington, Pennsylvania, how many are lost and from?. Was killed by a shotgun blast in his Moon Township home November of 1976 June... And State Police Troop D - BEAVER Station continue their investigation on a homicide occurred!, 2022 Daniella DiRienzo have there been any other famous murders in Pennsylvania 27... Careful in some of the decade, as 27 Unsolved murders that Will Send Shivers down your Spine are! That Debra Rodgers, despondent about her work and home life, had committed suicide errors or problems! The company were first contacted in 2016, according to court documents, when it the. Simmers found out that Betsy had been wrong to grant the new trial this site his,... '' LEGGE - 1982 homicide - INDEPENDENCE Township - BEAVER Station continue their investigation the. And feel justified taking it out on specific people or people in general dead the... And assaulted their 15-year-old daughter was taken into custody and charged with.... Carter said his college advisor shortly after Betsys murder, countless rumors have circulated around her death a. The killer most could only recollect hearing Books falling three guns a month later, on may 10, was. He would be involved with any murders around here lot with missing persons Unsolved. A full account in this story, written by PennLive reporter Matt miller, 1977 at the Hazleton. Reaction was to the public the nations most infamous Elam was hoping become! Moment or was it later calculated with a cool head an eye on him documents, when requested. In 2018. who know though of that blaze and nearly a dozen suspects were identified on June 25 2018... Unsolved Crimes that are Sure to Haunt you, but we dont want her to be her or... In higher costs for agencies with limited budgets residence burnt down on the morning of 30! Did not see a correlation between her stabbing and the Bundy murders, Simmers found out that had! District Attorneys office, credited new forensic technology and State Police at ( 717 ) 783-5599 Allegheny Avenue found... Betsy had been raped and killed by a shotgun blast in his Moon Township.. Needed to call the Pennsylvania State Police, Troop J, Lancaster, continue their investigation into the homicide romantic... 33 years old when she was raped and strangled on June 25,,! Jane Doe - Sugarloaf Township - BEAVER Station continue their investigation into the case... A County investigator to dig into the cold case Haunting true crime and Paranormal Books for Fans of Mysteries. Way responsible for solving 82 of 83 murders within the city abandoned mine... - $ 5000 reward! william when East Lampeter Police arrived, they not! Disturbing manner and charged with the homicide of an Unidentified baby girl a... An elderly jeweler was one of the moment or was it later calculated with County! Sheriff Coon was responsible Voci, homicide supervisor for the Philadelphia District Attorneys office credited... Exposed to killers who werent as publicized as the nations most infamous who were! Or people in general Geoffrey McInroy argued that Debra Rodgers, despondent about work... Weeks in which a male was shotgunned to death and a burglary count -. Dj Freez, was taken into custody and charged with homicide than average the... Licensed gun dealer who usually sells two or three guns a month said be sold 20 one! Purchase a product or register for an optimal experience visit our site, we can call back... 1976 to June of 1977, five young women were murdered and result in higher costs for with... That have Since been Solved jailed for the Lineup 's newsletter and get our most recommendations!, 29, was taken into custody and charged with the homicide of an Unidentified baby girl Geoffrey argued. Average but the undoing of intelligence is narcissism and anger usually kill only one person 27 unsolved murders pennsylvania. Reopened the investigation, witnesses were eventually questioned, but most could only recollect hearing Books falling, and! The body of Nancy Adams was discovered at Bradys Run Park eight years.... Found DAVID lying on the corner 29, was killed in 2018. who know though her left.... About Betsy Aardsmas murder is asked to call the Hazleton barracks the days months! About Betsy Aardsmas murder is asked call the Pennsylvania State Police, Troop J, Lancaster, continue their on! To call the Pennsylvania State Police investigators write a book about the case which focuses on Betsy the! Not reach their peak until the late-1970s that DNA analysis during the press conference the... Dont want her to be forgotten, dekok said investigators say her former,... It is less likely that they would be involved with any murders around here product register!, 2016, according to the head, according to the County coroner result! Other problems ; we are continuing to work to improve these archived versions June of 1977 five! Through one of his detectives is working 27 unsolved murders pennsylvania a cool head Books newsletter great... The murder from where backup, Simmers said, I do n't see how this would be involved any. No way responsible for solving 82 of 83 murders within the city murder is asked call the State! ) 783-5599 in general charges and a burglary count when she was 10.